TotalEnergies Climate Accountability
Paris Court Rules TotalEnergies Must Account for Customer Emissions, Widening Corporate Climate Responsibility
Anonymous
Key Points
1
NGOs argue that end-user emissions from TotalEnergies' products amounted to about 342 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent in 2024, underscoring a sizable Scope 3 impact that the court has now acknowledged must be accounted for.
2
Judges described Scope 3 emissions as part of the negative impacts resulting from TotalEnergies' own operations due to the inherent link between oil and gas production and the combustion of the products.
3
City of Paris Deputy Mayor Alice Timsit called the ruling a landmark decision, arguing that climate risks fall under the duty of vigilance and that no fossil-fuel multinational can evade responsibility.
4
TotalEnergies has outlined a diversification path, aiming for power to represent about 20% of its energy output by 2030 and signaling it will not pursue net-zero emission targets by 2050.
A Paris court ruled on June 25, 2026, that TotalEnergies must account for the carbon emissions its customers produce by burning its oil and gas products. The Paris Judicial Court ordered the French energy giant to update its governance plan within six months to cover these so-called Scope 3 emissions — those generated not by the company itself, but by end users of its products. The Guardian reported the ruling marks the first time a French court has directly linked a company's sales to the global climate crisis.
The court stopped short of ordering TotalEnergies to halt overseas exploration or cut production. But judges said the extraction and sale of oil
Six Years of Litigation Finally Yields a Legal Breakthrough
The case dates back to January 2020, when 14 local authorities and a coalition of NGOs — including Sherpa and Notre Affaire à Tous — filed suit under France's 2017 Duty of Vigilance law. That law requires large companies to identify and prevent risks to human rights and the environment. Until this ruling, it was unclear whether
The path to a verdict was slow. A Nanterre court rejected TotalEnergies' attempt to move the case in 2021. The Paris Court of Appeal declared the action admissible in June 2024. Final hearings on the merits took place in February 2026. A follow-up hearing is now scheduled for January 2027 to review TotalEnergies' updated compliance plan, according to Associated Press.
342 Million Tonnes: Why Scope 3 Emissions Are the Real Fight
NGOs estimate that TotalEnergies' Scope 3 emissions — the CO2 released when customers burn its products — totaled about 342 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent in 2024, according to The Hindu. That dwarfs the company's direct operational emissions. Judges ruled these emissions are
TotalEnergies pushed back hard. Company lawyers argued the firm cannot be held responsible for a
Paris Hails Ruling as Historic, TotalEnergies Claims Partial Win
City of Paris Deputy Mayor Alice Timsit called it
TotalEnergies, for its part, expressed
Ruling Sets Stage for Wider Corporate Climate Accountability in Europe
Legal experts say the court's framing creates a significant opening for future cases. Because Scope 3 emissions are now ruled
The ruling follows a 2024 UK Supreme Court decision requiring planners to weigh the climate impact of burning extracted fossil fuels when approving drilling permits. It also builds on the 2021 Shell ruling in the Netherlands, which was partly overturned in 2024. TotalEnergies has six months to submit a revised vigilance plan. The January 2027 court review will determine whether its response is sufficient, according to Seeking Alpha.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
14
Articles
37
Reach
51
A
AnonymousAuthor
