Bears Quarterback Dilemma
Chicago Bears Weigh Backup Quarterback Options Following Caleb Williams Hamstring Injury
Anonymous
Key Points
1
Williams’ injury was a non-contact incident, and he was carted off the field; the Bears planned imaging to determine its severity, details that initially raised concern he could miss multiple weeks.
2
Case Keenum’s potential start would be his first since 2023, when he started for Houston; he is also known for leading Minnesota’s “Minneapolis Miracle” playoff comeback.
3
Ben Johnson has never had to prepare a regular-season backup quarterback in Chicago or Detroit, and his experience calling plays for Case Keenum this season was limited because play-calling was often handed over during preseason games.
4
Bagent’s limited experience was cited as a concern: since his rookie season in 2023, he had not played more than five games in a season or thrown more than 10 passes in a season.
5
Garoppolo had not signed with a team during the offseason because he was uncertain whether he wanted to continue playing, but the article argued that joining Johnson’s offense and working with Chicago’s offensive weapons could entice him back.
Caleb Williams' hamstring injury has forced the Chicago Bears to scramble for quarterback options. The rookie star was carted off during a 9-3 loss to Minnesota and is considered week to week, Sports Illustrated reported. Backup Tyson Bagent faces his own concussion concerns, likely elevating Case Keenum to starter if Williams cannot play.
Coach Ben Johnson now faces an unfamiliar challenge: preparing his offense around a backup quarterback. Sports Illustrated noted the Bears could explore trades for veteran insurance like Mason Rudolph, Jimmy Garoppolo, or Jake Browning. Williams' injury is not yet considered severe enough to guarantee an immediate roster move, but the team is preparing contingency plans.
Williams Carted Off With Non-Contact Hamstring Injury
Williams went down during the second quarter of Chicago's loss without any contact from an opposing player. A to Z Sports reported the Bears immediately called for medical staff to cart him off the field. Imaging was planned to determine if the injury could sideline him for multiple weeks or longer.
The non-contact nature of the injury raised early concerns about severity. However, the Bears have since classified Williams as week to week rather than out for an extended period. This classification suggests the injury may not be as severe as initial fears, though his immediate availability remains unlikely.
Keenum Steps In If Bagent Cannot Clear Concussion Protocol
Case Keenum would likely start if both Williams and Bagent are unavailable. Q985 Online noted this would be Keenum's first start since 2023, when he started for the Houston Texans. Keenum is also famous for leading Minnesota's "Minneapolis Miracle" playoff comeback, showcasing he can perform in high-pressure moments.
Ben Johnson's experience calling plays for Keenum this season was limited. During preseason games, play-calling duties were often handed over to other coaches. Johnson has never had to prepare a regular-season backup quarterback in Chicago or during his time with Detroit, making this a new test for the offensive coordinator.
Bears Could Target Veteran Trade Options to Back Up Rotation
Mason Rudolph emerged as a potential target because of his playoff experience. Sports Illustrated reported Rudolph went 3-0 late in the 2023 season and helped the Pittsburgh Steelers reach the playoffs. He has 19 career starts and could provide immediate depth. However, Pittsburgh may resist trading him as Aaron Rodgers' backup insurance.
Jimmy Garoppolo and Jake Browning are also in the mix. A to Z Sports suggested Garoppolo had avoided signing during the offseason because he was unsure about continuing his playing career. However, joining Johnson's offense and working with Chicago's talented weapons could interest him in returning to football.
Bagent's Limited Experience Raises Concerns About Depth Chart
Tyson Bagent's backup role comes with significant limitations. Since his 2023 rookie season, he had not played more than five games in a single season or thrown more than 10 passes annually. Q985 Online cited his limited experience as a concern for the Bears' offensive continuity if he had to start.
The combination of Williams' injury and Bagent's concussion status has exposed the Bears' thin quarterback depth. Unless the team makes an immediate trade, Chicago would rely on backup options with minimal recent game experience. This uncertainty adds pressure to Johnson's play-calling and overall game preparation.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
17
Articles
29
Reach
46
A
AnonymousAuthor
