Canucks' Draft Struggles
Vancouver Canucks Face History of Underperforming Second-Round Draft Picks
Anonymous
The Vancouver Canucks have spent more than two decades turning the second round of the NHL Draft into a talent graveyard. Since 2002, the team has selected a string of players who combined for fewer than 15 NHL games in a Canucks uniform, according to The Province. Names like Denis Grot, Taylor Ellington, Yann Sauve, and Alexandre Mallet fill a list that analysts now call the franchise's second-round "black hole."
Now, under a front office in full rebuild mode, Vancouver is betting that 2026 marks the turning point. The Canucks entered this year's draft with four picks in the first two rounds — the most in franchise history — and management says getting younger is the top priority, according to Calgary Herald.
Two Decades of Second-Round Busts Since 2002
The black hole begins in 2002, when Vancouver selected Kirill Koltsov 49th overall and Denis Grot 55th. Neither played a meaningful NHL game. In 2003, Marc-Andre Bernier went 60th — same result. The Gillis era from 2007 to 2012 deepened the damage. Taylor Ellington (2007), Yann Sauve (2008), Anton Rodin (2009), and Alexandre Mallet (2012) appeared in a combined fewer than 15 NHL games for the Canucks, according to Edmonton Sun.
Rare bright spots existed but stayed rare. Mason Raymond, picked 51st in 2005, reached the 2011 Stanley Cup Final. Thatcher Demko, taken 36th in 2014, became a starter. Nils Hoglander, selected 40th in 2019, earned roster time before being traded to Nashville in June 2026. These three are outliers in a list dominated by players who never suited up, according to National Post.
"Stiffness" Philosophy Cost the Team a Generation of Skill
For years, Canucks management chased what insiders called "stiffness" — size, physical play, and defensive toughness — over speed and skill. Former GM Jim Benning explained the mindset after trading Kevin Bieksa, saying the team had become "too easy to play against." That thinking pushed scouts toward big, physical players who often lacked the skating ability to survive the modern NHL, according to The Province.
In 2017, the team picked Kole Lind 33rd and Jonah Gadjovich 55th, both with high expectations. Both were eventually lost via waivers or minor trades. Analyst Thomas Drance noted that trading away second and third-round picks for aging veterans during the Benning era made the few remaining picks "must-hits" — and the team kept missing, according to Toronto Sun.
Quinn Hughes Trade and a Full Rebuild Now Underway
The collapse of the 2025-26 season forced the Canucks into a hard reset. Captain Quinn Hughes was traded to the Minnesota Wild in a package that returned Zeev Buium, Marco Rossi, Liam Ohgren, and the pick used on Adam Novotny 24th overall in 2026. GM Patrik Allvin confirmed the direction plainly: "We are transitioning into a rebuild here... the draft is really important for us," according to Mitchell Advocate.
The Canucks also selected Brooks Rogowski 33rd and Niklas Aaram-Olsen 41st in the second round of the 2026 draft. Current GM Ryan Johnson said the goal is clear: "We want to continue to acquire young players and draft picks in order to continue to build our roster... getting younger is the emphasis." On opening night of 2025-26, Vancouver was already the sixth-youngest team in the league, according to The Whig.
Farm System Finally Getting the Talent It Has Long Lacked
The Abbotsford Canucks, Vancouver's AHL affiliate, are the early winners of this new approach. For years, analysts described the farm system as thin. Now prospects like Jonathan Lekkerimaki and Tom Willander are pushing through the pipeline. A study of Canucks drafting from 2010 to 2020 found a second and third-round conversion rate of just 21.4%, ranking them 30th out of 32 NHL teams in production per draft pick, according to LF Press.
The path forward is not without risk. Reports from April 2026 suggested that team president Jim Rutherford and GM Patrik Allvin were "not on the same page" regarding how long the rebuild should take, according to Brantford Expositor. With Danila Klimovich, picked 41st in 2021, still without a regular NHL role, the pressure to finally hit on second-round picks has never been higher.
Sentiment
NeutralNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
11
Articles
10
Reach
11
A
AnonymousAuthor
