Phillies' Bullpen Challenges

Four Home Runs in One Inning Sink Phillies

Lefty Tanner Banks entered in relief of starter Alan Rangel in the fourth inning. What followed was a disaster. The Reds hit four home runs that inning — three of them off Banks back-to-back-to-back, according to The News Tribune. It was the kind of collapse that turns a close game into a blowout in minutes.

Banks now carries an ERA of 7.14 on the season. The numbers show he has not been reliable in this role. The Phillies had limited options to turn to, which made the damage worse.

1 source

Alvarado Struggles Again in Seventh Inning

After Banks gave up the big fourth inning, the Phillies turned to José Alvarado in the seventh. He was charged with four more runs, per Bellingham Herald. Alvarado's ERA now sits at 7.03 on the season. Two key relievers with ERAs above 7.00 is a major red flag for any contending team.

1 source

Left-Handed Relief Depth Down to One Option

The Phillies' lefty relief problem goes beyond just bad outings. Before this game, the team optioned Kyle Backhus due to his struggles, according to Star-Telegram. That move left Tim Mayza as the only left-handed option in the entire bullpen. One lefty is a razor-thin margin for a team trying to win a division.

Lefty specialists matter because they match up against left-handed hitters — batters who often have a big edge against right-handed pitchers. With just Mayza available, opposing managers can pick spots to exploit the Phillies all game long.

1 source

Fifth Starter Spot Has Become a Recurring Liability

Nine straight losses when the fifth starter takes the mound is not bad luck — it is a pattern, according to Tri-City Herald. The fifth spot in a rotation is typically the weakest, but this level of futility puts pressure on the rest of the staff. Every game from that slot now feels like a must-survive situation for the bullpen.

The Phillies will need to make a move if they want to stay competitive. Whether that means a trade, a call-up from the minors, or a rotation shuffle, the current setup is not working. The numbers make that impossible to ignore.

1 source