Conflicting Batman Casting Rumors
New Reports Contradict Sebastian Stan's Casting as Harvey Dent in 'The Batman: Part II'
Anonymous
Key Points
1
Reeves’ early production-day communications included a May 14 tweet thread that welcomed new cast members but “didn’t specify which characters the actors are playing,” underscoring how closely the roles remain guarded.
2
Multiple outlets contradict Sneider’s Zsasz/Dent swap: Variety reported that “Stan is playing Dent,” with “Charles Dance playing Dent’s father and Scarlett Johansson playing Dent’s wife, Gilda,” and Deadline’s interview with Stan included remarks that “seemed to imply” he’d play Dent and his villainous alter ego.
3
Sneider’s reporting also adds that his sources would not share details about Johansson and Dance’s parts, and that the two are “melds” of lesser-known characters—without identifying which ones.
4
While Sneider says Brian Tyree Henry will play Harvey Dent, he also suggests Dent “won’t necessarily become Two-Face in the film,” separating the sequel’s Dent storyline from the classic transformation expectation.
5
The Victor Zsasz rumor is grounded in the character’s published comic history: Zsasz was “created by Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle” and first appeared in 1992’s Batman: Shadow of the Bat #1.
A new insider report claims Sebastian Stan will not play Harvey Dent in *The Batman: Part II* — but instead will portray Victor Zsasz, a sadistic serial killer who carves tally marks into his own skin for each victim. The InSneider reported on June 12 that Brian Tyree Henry will take the Harvey Dent role, upending months of trade reporting that had pointed squarely at Stan as Gotham's future Two-Face.
The film, directed by Matt Reeves and set for a U.S. release on October 1, 2027, entered production with its full cast still officially unannounced. Warner Bros. and DC Studios have confirmed nothing about which actors play which roles.
Months of 'Dent Family' Reports Now Under Dispute
Since January 2026, major trades pointed to a clear story: Stan as Harvey Dent, Charles Dance as Dent's father, and Scarlett Johansson as Dent's wife, Gilda. Variety reported those specific roles directly. Deadline added that Stan's own comments "seemed to imply" he would play Dent and his villainous alter ego, Two-Face.
On May 14, Matt Reeves posted a cast announcement thread on X that welcomed Stan, Johansson, Dance, and Brian Tyree Henry to "Gotham City" — but Slash Film noted he "didn't specify which characters the actors are playing." That silence left the door open for exactly the kind of reversal now being reported.
Who Is Victor Zsasz — and Why Does It Matter?
Zsasz is a Batman villain created by Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle. He first appeared in 1992's *Batman: Shadow of the Bat* #1. His defining trait: he carves a tally mark into his own skin for every person he kills. Slash Film notes his live-action appearances have been minor — a small role in *Batman Begins* (2005) and a comedic version in *Birds of Prey* (2020) — meaning a full cinematic portrayal would be new ground.
That lines up with Reeves' own comments. He described the Part II villain as something "never really been done in a movie before," according to insider reporting. JobLo also noted Stan was spotted with a shaved head — a look consistent with how Zsasz is drawn in the comics. The sequel is framed, per Reel360, as another "serial killer murder mystery" like the 2022 original.
Brian Tyree Henry as Dent — With a Twist
If Sneider's report holds, Henry would be the first Black actor to play Harvey Dent in live-action since Billy Dee Williams in 1989's *Batman*. But the role may be smaller than fans expect. Sneider's sources say Dent "won't necessarily become Two-Face" in this film. That suggests Reeves may be saving the full transformation for a third installment.
Movie Web reports that the Court of Owls — a secret society of Gotham's elite — will also appear in the sequel. That adds a political conspiracy layer on top of the Zsasz serial-killer story. It positions Dent as one pressure point in a larger web of institutional rot, rather than the film's central villain.
Johansson and Dance Roles Still a Mystery
Sneider's sources would not say exactly who Johansson and Dance are playing. His report describes their characters only as "melds" of lesser-known comic figures — not the Gilda and Christopher Dent roles that Variety had previously named. Slash Film noted this is a significant departure from the "Dent Family" arc that had defined the sequel's early narrative identity.
The conflicting reports set up what analysts are calling a "Sneider vs. trades" test. If Stan appears on set with Zsasz's characteristic scars, or Henry is photographed in a DA's office, independent insiders will score a major win over outlets like Variety. Until then, both versions of the story remain live — and Warner Bros. is saying nothing.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
20
Articles
24
Reach
44
A
AnonymousAuthor
