Instagram's Moderation Failure
BBC Investigation Reveals Instagram Promoted Child Abuse Ads in India, Exposing Moderation Failures
Anonymous
Key Points
1
Meta says criminals try to evade detection, and its expert teams are continually working to improve defenses, block links to violating websites, and share intelligence with other companies to take action.
2
India’s top cyber police official, Shikha Goel, noted that Instagram and Facebook generate the most tipline reports, and she said that if the platforms have effective algorithms to track child sexual abuse material, more alerts will naturally be generated—highlighting the complexity of measuring platform scale from tips alone.
3
Telegram reported removing over 274,000 groups and channels related to child sexual abuse material in 2026, signaling ongoing moderation challenges beyond the social apps.
4
BBC’s alias Instagram account experiment showed that after following about 10 accounts linked to sexualised content, within a week the platform began surfacing ads for video calls with women and for clearly naked couples, illustrating rapid algorithmic exposure to exploitative material.
5
One of the BBC-tracked ads depicted a young girl appearing distressed, implying she had been sexually assaulted, underscoring the severity of exploitative content circulating via Instagram ads in India.
Instagram approved paid ads in India that directed users to child sexual abuse material, a BBC Eye investigation has found. The ads used explicit terms like "rape video" and "child video" and linked to Telegram channels where the content was sold for about 99 rupees — roughly $1.20. BBC reported that at least one ad was initially flagged as compliant by Instagram's own moderation system before the outlet raised the issue directly with Meta.
After BBC contacted the company, Meta said it had disabled the ads and suspended the accounts behind them. But the investigation exposed serious gaps in how Instagram screens paid content — and how its algorithm can rapidly funnel users toward exploitative material, Digital Trends reported.
How the Ads Slipped Through Instagram's Review System
The ads were paid promotions, meaning they went through Meta's ad approval process before reaching users. Despite containing terms explicitly referencing rape and children, the system initially cleared at least one of them. Meta later acknowledged that its review processes "may miss violations," according to Digital Trends. The company said criminals actively try to evade detection and that expert teams are working to improve defenses.
Once a user clicked the ads, they were sent to Telegram channels where child sexual abuse material could be purchased. The investigation found the content was being sold openly at low prices, making it easy to access. Meta said it also blocks links to violating websites and shares intelligence with other companies to help take further action, Arise TV reported.
BBC's Algorithm Test Revealed Rapid Exposure to Exploitative Content
BBC researchers created a test Instagram account and followed about 10 accounts linked to sexualized content. Within one week, the platform began showing ads for video calls with women and ads featuring clearly naked couples. The experiment shows how quickly Instagram's algorithm can push users toward harmful material — even without searching for it, Digital Trends reported.
One ad tracked by BBC showed a young girl who appeared distressed, with the content implying she had been sexually assaulted. The ad was a paid promotion, meaning someone paid Meta money to display it to Indian users. This detail alarmed child safety advocates and Indian officials alike, according to Storyboard18.
Indian Officials and a Retired Judge Question Platform Responsibility
India's top cyber police official, Shikha Goel, noted that Instagram and Facebook generate the most reports to the country's tipline for child abuse material. She said platforms with strong tracking algorithms will naturally produce more alerts — but the volume of tips still signals a serious problem on both platforms, Arise TV reported.
A retired Supreme Court justice also raised concerns, questioning whether Meta was profiting from criminal activity by running these ads. The criticism puts pressure on Meta to do more than suspend individual accounts after the fact. Indian officials are now calling for platforms to build stronger front-end defenses, according to Storyboard18.
Telegram Removed 274,000 Abuse Channels, But Problems Persist
Telegram said it removed over 274,000 groups and channels related to child sexual abuse material in 2026 alone. That number signals the scale of the problem — and how much illegal content is still being hosted and sold on the platform, according to Timeline Daily.
The BBC investigation shows this is not just a Telegram problem. Instagram's ad system served as the entry point, funneling buyers toward illegal content hosted elsewhere. Together, the findings point to a gap that runs across multiple platforms — and one that neither Meta nor Telegram has fully closed, Digital Trends reported.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
17
Articles
23
Reach
40
A
AnonymousAuthor
