Mosque Loudspeaker Control
Knesset Advances Muezzin Bill to Regulate Mosque Loudspeakers Amidst Political Opposition
Anonymous
Key Points
1
The bill would ban installing or operating any mosque loudspeaker system without explicit prior authorization, effectively stripping the adhan of its practical purpose and turning on a formal permit regime for mosque sound systems.
2
Key party dynamics around the vote included United Torah Judaism absent from the ballot due to an alleged understanding with Arab parties, while Shas publicly supported the measure and Yisrael Beytenu backed it, underscoring shifting coalition calculations.
3
Arab political factions criticized the legislation as targeting Israel's Muslim minority, with Ra’am condemning Shas' support and Abbas calling the backing of the bill disappointing and reprehensible.
4
The muezzin bill is not the first effort—several versions have circulated for years, including a prominent earlier proposal by Moti Yogev and a 2017 iteration, reflecting a long-running debate on mosque loudspeakers.
5
Explanatory notes frame the bill within a broader context of heightened concern over mosque loudspeaker noise, citing cross-country examples (including Egypt and Saudi Arabia) and noting that some countries restrict or ban such uses; one article ties the discussion to post-October 7 developments.
Israel's Knesset advanced a bill on July 1, 2026 that would ban mosque loudspeakers without a government permit, passing its first vote 50–36. Ynet News reported the legislation — dubbed the "muezzin bill" — would require mosques to get explicit authorization before operating any sound system, empower police to enter mosques to seize equipment, and impose fines up to 50,000 NIS (about $13,500) for violations.
The bill, sponsored by Otzma Yehudit MK Zvika Fogel and backed by National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, still needs committee review and three more Knesset votes before it becomes law. Arab lawmakers called it a direct attack on Muslim religious life. Supporters say it is simply a noise-control measure applied equally to all.
What the Bill Would Actually Do to Mosques
Under the proposed law, no mosque could install or run a public address system without prior government authorization, according to Yahoo News. Permits would be judged on noise intensity, the mosque's location, and its proximity to homes. Police could enter a house of worship mid-prayer to stop a violation and confiscate equipment if the problem persists.
Fines are steep. Operating a loudspeaker without a permit carries a 50,000 NIS ($13,500) penalty. Breaking permit conditions costs 10,000 NIS ($2,700). TRT World noted the bill targets what proponents call "mosque noise" — framing the adhan, the Islamic call to prayer, as an environmental nuisance rather than a protected religious act.
Shas Backs the Bill, UTJ Quietly Steps Away
The 50–36 vote exposed sharp divisions inside Israel's coalition. Shas, the Sephardic ultra-Orthodox party, voted yes — a surprise, since Haredi parties have long feared noise laws could also target Jewish Sabbath sirens. Their support signaled a return to coalition discipline after a recent boycott of votes, Ynet News reported.
United Torah Judaism lawmakers were absent entirely. Reports suggest a quiet deal: Arab MKs would abstain on a separate "Torah Study Basic Law" vote in exchange for UTJ sitting out the muezzin bill. Opposition party Yisrael Beytenu also voted in favor, showing that support for the measure crosses the coalition-opposition divide.
Arab Leaders Call It Religious Targeting, Not Noise Control
Ra'am leader Mansour Abbas called Shas's support "reprehensible" and "disappointing." Hadash-Ta'al chairman Ayman Odeh went further, saying Ben-Gvir was "persecuting a religious minority" while Arab communities faced a surge in violence. MK Ofer Cassif put it bluntly: "The muezzin does not disturb their ears; it disturbs their racism," according to TRT World.
Sheikh Ekrima Sabri, the Imam of Al-Aqsa Mosque, warned the bill had taken a "dangerous turn" by legalizing a ban on the call to prayer. Arab lawmakers also cautioned that giving police the power to enter mosques and seize equipment could spark civil unrest, especially during sensitive religious holidays, Ynet News reported.
A Decade of Failed Muezzin Bills Behind This Vote
This is not the first attempt. Similar bills surfaced in 2017 and were championed earlier by MK Moti Yogev, but all fell apart over coalition friction and Haredi fears about Jewish noise restrictions. Ben-Gvir already tried a softer approach in late 2024, ordering police to confiscate mosque speakers under existing noise rules — but enforcement stalled after pushback from Arab leaders, according to Ynet News.
Supporters point to regulations in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and parts of Europe that cap mosque loudspeaker volume. MK Fogel argued the bill simply closes a gap in Israel's 1961 Abatement of Nuisances Law, which critics say has been nearly impossible to enforce against mosques. If the bill passes all four readings, legal challenges at the High Court of Justice are widely expected on religious discrimination grounds, democrata.es noted.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
12
Articles
6
Reach
18
Topics
A
AnonymousAuthor
