Florida Authorities Charge Ten Suspects in Massive Illegal Commercial Fishing Scheme

Authorities say the group evaded reporting rules by selling fish at night from docks, from private homes, and through handoffs on the water.
The three suspects accused of selling turtles to undercover officers were identified as Terry Carrington, Anthony Folsom, and Jordan Neylan; authorities said the five turtles included three adults and two hatchlings.
The 10 defendants face charges including racketeering, conspiracy to commit racketeering, cheating, unlawful possession or sale of sea turtles, and unlawful use of a two-way communication device.
Franklin County Sheriff AJ “Tony” Smith said the exploitation affects the community and the livelihoods of people who depend on local natural resources.
Florida authorities have charged 10 people in a multi-year undercover investigation into an illegal commercial fishing operation that poached about 23,000 pounds of fish and sold over $150,000 worth of protected sea turtles, shrimp, and illegally caught fish. Florida Voice News reports that three suspects sold undercover officers five sea turtles, including two hatchlings, in what prosecutors say represents a widespread racketeering scheme designed to exploit the state's marine resources.
The defendants face serious charges including racketeering, conspiracy, and unlawful possession of endangered sea turtles. Your Sun reports that Franklin County Sheriff AJ "Tony" Smith said the operation harmed the community and threatened the livelihoods of people who depend on local fisheries.
The group sold their catch through unconventional channels to avoid detection. CBS 12 reports they conducted sales at night from docks, private homes, and through handoffs directly on the water. This strategy allowed them to sidestep legal reporting requirements that legitimate commercial fishermen must follow.
Investigators documented the illegal harvests of red snapper and gag grouper—both species with strict catch limits in Florida waters. The operation generated substantial profits while operating almost entirely outside the regulated fishing industry.
Three suspects—Terry Carrington, Anthony Folsom, and Jordan Neylan—allegedly supplied five sea turtles directly to law enforcement officers working undercover. Fox 49 reports the turtles included three adults and two hatchlings, all protected species under federal law. The sales represented a critical piece of evidence in building the prosecution's case.
The 10 defendants face multiple felony counts tied to their alleged operations. According to Your Sun, charges include racketeering, conspiracy to commit racketeering, cheating, unlawful possession or sale of sea turtles, and unlawful use of a two-way communication device. The racketeering charges suggest prosecutors view this as an organized criminal enterprise rather than isolated violations.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed the charges as part of a broader effort to protect the state's marine resources. The investigation, which began in 2022, represents one of the most significant wildlife trafficking cases in the region. Court proceedings are ongoing.
Publishers
12
Articles
42
Reach
54