Weinstein Conviction Affirmed
Harvey Weinstein's Rape Conviction Affirmed, Sentence Vacated; New York Case Dropped
Anonymous
Key Points
1
An appeals panel unanimously rejected Weinstein's bid to overturn the jury's verdicts, affirming the conviction on one count of rape and two counts of sexual assault while vacating the sentence and remanding for resentencing.
2
The panel found the original sentencing was not properly justified under California sentencing guidelines for sexual assault and directed a new sentencing hearing, with the attorney general's office agreeing to the upholding of the conviction while resentencing.
3
Weinstein's 16-year term was broke down into eight years for forcible rape, six years for forcible oral copulation, and two years for sexual penetration by a foreign object.
4
The New York case tied to Weinstein was dropped after prosecutors said the accuser could not testify again, a development that followed the California ruling ordering resentencing.
5
Weinstein’s lawyers have signaled they'll continue pursuing appeals, including seeking review in the California Supreme Court.
A California appeals court unanimously upheld Harvey Weinstein's 2022 rape conviction on Friday, June 26, but threw out his 16-year prison sentence and ordered a new sentencing hearing, according to NBC Los Angeles. The three-judge panel from the California 2nd District Court of Appeal found the conviction solid but said the original sentence was not properly calculated under state guidelines.
The ruling came one day after Manhattan prosecutors dropped a separate rape charge involving accuser Jessica Mann, who told the court she could not endure a fourth trial, AP News reported. Weinstein's spokesperson called the appellate decision "disappointing" but acknowledged the court "correctly recognized that his sentence cannot stand."
Why the 16-Year Sentence Was Thrown Out
When Judge Lisa B. Lench sentenced Weinstein in February 2023, she used his 2020 New York conviction as an aggravating factor — meaning a reason to add more time. That New York conviction was overturned in April 2024. With the foundation gone, the California sentence could not stand, NBC Chicago reported. The California Attorney General's office agreed the sentence needed to be reviewed.
The original 16-year term was broken into three parts: 8 years for forcible rape, 6 years for forcible oral copulation, and 2 years for sexual penetration by a foreign object. At resentencing, Judge Lench could still reach a similar total by citing other factors — such as the victim's vulnerability. But Weinstein's lawyers will push for the counts to run at the same time rather than back-to-back, which would cut his California time significantly, according to Big News Network.
Conviction Stands Firm Despite Defense Challenges
Weinstein's lawyers had argued the trial was "infected" by jurors knowing about his then-existing New York conviction. They also said Judge Lench unfairly blocked testimony from a film festival executive who could have challenged the accuser's account. The appellate panel rejected both arguments and refused to "disturb the jury's guilty verdicts," according to NBC Boston.
The conviction covers crimes against Evgeniya Chernyshova, an Italian model and actress identified as Jane Doe 1 at trial. She later went public and filed a civil suit. The 3-0 vote by the appeals panel leaves the guilty verdicts on all three counts fully intact. Weinstein's team now plans to petition the California Supreme Court, NBC Connecticut reported.
New York Case Collapses as Jessica Mann Walks Away
One day before the California ruling, Manhattan prosecutors asked a judge to dismiss a third-degree rape charge against Weinstein involving accuser Jessica Mann. Prosecutor Nicole Blumberg said the office would "hail her bravery, strength, courage and inspiration to other survivors" but that "dismissal is appropriate" because Mann could not testify again, AP News reported. Judge Curtis Farber formally dismissed the case on June 25, 2026.
Mann had already participated in three trial juries and two grand juries. The dismissal does not affect Weinstein's remaining New York conviction tied to accuser Miriam Haley. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg's office is seeking a 20-year sentence on that count, with a hearing expected in September 2026, according to the Washington Post.
What Comes Next for the 74-Year-Old Weinstein
Weinstein is currently 74 and in poor health. His legal team will use both his age and health as arguments for a lighter sentence at the California resentencing hearing. More than 80 women have publicly accused Weinstein of misconduct since 2017, when reporting by The Guardian and others ignited the global #MeToo movement.
Under legal protocols, Weinstein will likely serve any new New York sentence first before returning to California. The California resentencing could come after the September 2026 New York hearing. Victim advocacy groups tied to #MeToo said the upheld California conviction remains a key legal win, even as the New York Mann case ended without a verdict, NBC Los Angeles reported.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
17
Articles
195
Reach
212
A
AnonymousAuthor
