Sara Graham cold case arrests.
Breakthrough in 11-year-old Sara Graham disappearance leads to three arrests.
Anonymous
Eleven years after 18-year-old Sara Graham vanished from Fairmont, North Carolina, her stepmother and two stepbrothers are now behind bars. Charlotte Observer reports that Connie Graham, 65, was charged with first-degree murder on June 25, 2026 — along with her sons Bobby Matthew McLellan and Luke Locklear — in what authorities are calling a major breakthrough in one of Robeson County's most haunting cold cases.
The arrests came just three weeks after a judge legally declared Sara dead. Sheriff Burnis Wilkins said: "Sara was never forgotten, and those responsible, no matter how hard they tried, did not outrun the pursuit of justice."
A Teen Vanishes and a Van Sits Empty
On February 4, 2015, Sara left her home on Centerville Church Road at 6:30 AM, heading to her Walmart shift in Pembroke. Just 15 minutes later, witnesses spotted her father's white Chevrolet Astro van parked in a wheat field off East McDonald Road. When deputies officially found the van at 12:15 PM, it was locked, undamaged, and showed no signs of a struggle. Sara was gone.
Sara had recently moved from Texas to live with her father and stepmother, Connie Graham. Connie was a 23-year veteran of the Robeson County Sheriff's Office. She was fired just six weeks after Sara vanished. Authorities cited a "personal matter" but gave no further details at the time, according to WMBF News.
A Legal Declaration of Death Unlocks Murder Charges
For a decade, investigators had no body and no charges. That changed on June 1, 2026, when a Robeson County Superior Court judge formally declared Sara dead. North Carolina law allows this after a person has been missing for seven years. WRAL reported that Sheriff Wilkins called this legal step a necessary move to go from a missing persons case to a murder prosecution.
The February 2025 ten-year anniversary had already seen the reward for information climb to $10,000 and the case officially reclassified as a homicide. The legal death declaration, experts say, gave prosecutors the foundation they needed to take the case to a grand jury — even without Sara's remains.
Charges Detail Burned Bedding and Destroyed Floors
Connie Graham faces first-degree murder, two counts of felony conspiracy, and destruction of criminal evidence. She is held without bond. Her son Bobby McLellan, 42, is charged with accessory after the fact, felony conspiracy, and evidence tampering. He is held on a $1 million secured bond. Luke Locklear, 29, faces felony conspiracy and evidence tampering charges, according to Hoodline.
Arrest warrants allege that Locklear helped burn evidence — specifically bedding and flooring. Legal analysts note that targeting household items like floors suggests forensic tools such as advanced DNA recovery or luminol testing of a "cleaned" scene finally gave investigators enough to act, Hoodline reports.
Sara's Body Still Missing as Prosecutors Plot Next Steps
Despite the arrests, Sara's remains have not been found. The FBI is still offering a $10,000 reward for information on their location. A preliminary hearing is set for July 2, 2026. Prosecutors may push to flip one of the sons against the other — or against Connie — to locate the body, Charlotte Observer reports.
The case has drawn wider attention from Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women advocates. The Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina, of which Sara was a member, called the arrests long overdue. Tribal Chairman John L. Lowery said: "Someone knows what happened to Sara and it is time to come forward." Sara's father, Hubert Graham, now serves as Chief of the Rowland Police Department. Investigators have not directed any suspicion at him.
Sentiment
NeutralNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
23
Articles
22
Reach
23
A
AnonymousAuthor
