Maple Leafs Carlo Trade
Toronto Maple Leafs Trade Defenceman Brandon Carlo to St. Louis Blues for Two 2026 Draft Picks
Anonymous
The Toronto Maple Leafs have traded defenceman Brandon Carlo to the St. Louis Blues for picks No. 73 and No. 76 in the 2026 NHL Draft, according to The Hockey News. The move, confirmed by Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman, frees up $3.485 million in cap space for Toronto ahead of the July 1 free agency period.
The deal is the fourth major trade in two weeks by new Toronto GM John Chayka. It marks a sharp reversal of the strategy built by his predecessor, Brad Treliving, who acquired Carlo just 15 months ago at a steep cost.
Treliving's Costly Carlo Bet Comes Undone
Treliving acquired Carlo from Boston on March 7, 2025, giving up top prospect Fraser Minten, a 2025 fourth-round pick, and a top-five protected 2026 first-round pick, TSN reported. The price looked steep at the time. It looks worse now. Minten scored 35 points for Boston in 2025-26, while Carlo posted just seven assists in 55 games with Toronto.
The Athletic's Chris Johnston called the original swap a trade that will "haunt the Maple Leafs for years," saying Boston "rinsed" Toronto in the deal. Toronto traded away a potential franchise center and a first-round pick and got back two mid-range third-rounders 15 months later.
Losing the Lottery Saved Toronto's First-Round Pick
There is one silver lining buried in Toronto's disastrous 2025-26 season. The Leafs finished 28th in the NHL and won the 2026 Draft Lottery. That triggered the top-five protection clause on the first-round pick owed to Boston. The pick now defers to 2027, per theScore.
On June 26, Toronto used that protected pick slot to select forward Gavin McKenna first overall, Sportsnet reported. Had the team performed better, they would have owed Boston a top pick and selected lower. The lottery loss turned into a lifeline.
Chayka Clears the Deck, Blues Get a Bargain
Chayka has now overhauled Toronto's defensive core almost entirely in under a month. He brought in Darren Raddysh from Tampa Bay and Emil Andrae from Philadelphia while also trading goalie Joseph Woll, according to NHL.com. Carlo is the latest piece of the old regime to go. Friedman noted the two-pick return was "light" but said Chayka's priority was cap flexibility.
St. Louis gets a 6-foot-5 veteran with 692 NHL games of experience for a low price. Carlo has one year left on his deal at $3.485 million. TSN's Pierre LeBrun suggested Carlo's departure could signal that Morgan Rielly is the next Leaf to be moved, as Toronto pivots toward a faster, more puck-moving defensive group.
Toronto Fans Embarrassed but Eyeing Free Agency
Fan reaction in Toronto has been mixed. theScore noted that analysts describe the entire Carlo saga as a "hallmark of the horrendous Treliving era." But most fans are looking forward, not back. With roughly $22.28 million in cap space now available, per PuckPedia via Hockey Patrol, Chayka has room to act on July 1.
The bigger picture is this: Toronto gave up a promising young center and a first-round pick for 75 games of Carlo and two third-rounders. The front office is now betting that clearing bad contracts and building around McKenna is the right path forward — even if the price of getting here was painfully high.
Sentiment
NeutralNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
4
Articles
2
Reach
4
Topics
A
AnonymousAuthor
