Federal Appeals Court Rules States Can Regulate Prediction Markets As Gambling

A federal appeals court has dealt a major blow to the prediction market industry by ruling that states can regulate these platforms as gambling. A three-judge panel of Trump-appointed judges from Nevada determined that prediction contracts are sports gambling under state law, regardless of how companies label them. WBAL reported the decision opens the door for states to shut down platforms like Kalshi and impose gaming taxes and regulations.
The ruling affects nine western states covered by the Ninth Circuit, including California and Arizona. Forty-four states have already argued that prediction markets should face state gambling laws. Legal experts say the decision could trigger a wave of state enforcement actions against the industry.
Nevada gaming regulators tried to shut down Kalshi, one of the largest prediction market platforms. The company argued its contracts were financial instruments, not gambling bets. The appeals court disagreed, saying the substance of the contracts makes them sports wagers under state law, KSBW reported.
Forty-four states have signed on to legal arguments that prediction markets should be treated as gambling. These states want platforms subject to gaming licenses, taxes, and oversight. WMUR noted the ruling validates state claims that these markets pose consumer protection risks and should generate tax revenue.
The Ninth Circuit decision creates binding legal precedent for nine western states, including California, Arizona, Washington, and Oregon. WVTM13 reported the ruling means federal judges in this region must follow the same reasoning when evaluating prediction market regulations. Other courts outside the circuit may cite the decision as persuasive authority.
The court's decision paves the way for other states to ban or heavily regulate prediction platforms. WCVB reported companies may need to get gaming licenses or exit regulated markets entirely. The ruling represents a significant setback for the booming prediction market industry, which has grown rapidly over the past few years.
Publishers
8
Articles
8
Reach
8