HOA's Controversial Geese Cull
Alabama HOA Board Votes to Euthanize Protected Geese Amid Resident Opposition
Anonymous
The Edgewater HOA board in Huntsville, Alabama, has voted to euthanize between 250 and 300 Canada geese living in the neighborhood. Board President Brian Goodwin says the birds have made walking trails unusable and pose a health risk, stating: "The sheer volume of waste has made our walking trails unusable and poses a genuine health risk to children and pets" WHNT News 19.
The birds are protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918. However, the USDA can legally issue permits to kill geese classified as a nuisance. The board has not reversed its decision, but angry residents are now seeking a legal injunction to stop the cull KCTV5.
300 Geese Produce 600 Pounds of Waste Daily
The scale of the problem is hard to ignore. A single Canada goose drops 1.5 to 2 pounds of waste per day. With roughly 300 geese in Edgewater, that adds up to 450 to 600 pounds of droppings deposited around the neighborhood every single day WALB.
The board says the geese have tripled in number since 2021. In 2019, Edgewater tried goose lights and chemical grass repellents. Those methods only worked temporarily. Goodwin says the board had no choice but to pursue what the USDA calls "Permanent Removal" — rounding up the flightless birds and killing them with carbon dioxide gas WDAM.
Residents Push Back With Petition and Protest
Not everyone agrees with the board. A Change.org petition titled "Save the Edgewater Geese" had collected 1,850 signatures as of June 13. Resident Sarah Vance, who helped organize an informal protest, called the cull a lazy fix. "Killing them is a lazy solution to a human-caused problem," she said. "We want a conservation-first approach" WAFB.
Residents are pushing for "addling" — shaking goose eggs to stop them from hatching — and using trained dogs to scare the birds away. A neighborhood poll found that over 50% of residents oppose lethal methods, while 40% support removal because of the mess WOWT.
Tight Summer Deadline Forces the Board's Hand
The USDA must act now because Canada geese molt — meaning they temporarily lose their flight feathers — in late June and early July. During this window, the birds cannot fly and are easy to round up. Once molting ends, the opportunity is gone until next year KCRG.
The HOA expects to pay the USDA between $3,000 and $7,000 for the service. Some residents threatening to withhold HOA dues in protest could create a budget shortfall for the community. The board voted in a closed-door session on June 8, and the specific vote count was not shared with residents, called a "confidential executive matter" WEAU.
Experts Warn Killing Geese May Not Solve the Problem
Wildlife biologist Dr. Marcus Hilliard says culling alone is often a short-term fix. "If the habitat remains attractive — short grass and clear sightlines to water — new geese will simply move into the vacuum left by the euthanized ones," he said WABI TV.
Removing the geese could benefit the neighborhood's lake in one way. Goose waste is high in nitrogen, which feeds toxic algae blooms. Environmentalists, however, argue the HOA created the problem by using "golf-course style" grass that attracts geese — and then chose the "cheapest, most violent" solution. Other large Huntsville communities are watching to see what happens next KAIT8.
Sentiment
NeutralNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
21
Articles
20
Reach
21
A
AnonymousAuthor
