Talarico Leads Paxton in Texas Senate Forecasts

Talarico is polling ahead of where Beto O’Rourke stood against Ted Cruz at a comparable point in the 2018 campaign, when O’Rourke came close to winning the Senate race.
The SoCal Strategies survey found that 6% of respondents who said they voted for President Donald Trump in 2024 were undecided in the Senate race, compared with just 1% of respondents who said they voted for Vice President Kamala Harris.
Republicans currently hold a 53-47 Senate majority, so Democrats would need to defend all of their existing seats and flip four Republican-held seats to regain control of the chamber.
Polymarket’s figures are trading-market prices rather than conventional polling or statistical forecasts; traders continuously buy and sell contracts tied to the election outcome, allowing the odds to change throughout the day.
Republican Sen. Ted Cruz warned that a Democratic victory in Texas could allow Democrats to “dominate the country for a century,” underscoring the broader national stakes Republicans attach to the race.
Democratic state Rep. James Talarico has pulled ahead of Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton in the closely watched Texas Senate race, marking a significant shift in a contest that could reshape the national political landscape. Newsweek reports that Talarico now leads in polls from eight different pollsters for the first time, with a SoCal Strategies survey showing him ahead 50%-45%, reversing Paxton's advantage from just months earlier.
Election forecasts and betting markets have shifted decisively in Talarico's favor. Prediction models now give him a 52%-58% chance of winning, while traders on Polymarket are pricing in substantial Democratic odds. A Talarico victory would be the first Democratic Senate win in Texas in decades and could help Democrats reclaim control of the chamber, where Republicans currently hold a 53-47 majority.
Talarico has made substantial gains among two critical voter groups that could decide the race. The SoCal Strategies poll shows him pulling support from Hispanic voters and independents who previously favored Paxton. Most remarkably, the survey found that 12% of Republicans surveyed are backing Talarico, suggesting erosion in Paxton's base even among traditional GOP voters.
The crossover appeal reveals a real vulnerability for Paxton heading into the final stretch. Trump voters show more weakness in the Senate race than Harris voters: 6% of Trump 2024 voters remain undecided on Senate compared to just 1% of Harris voters. This gap suggests Paxton faces a steeper path to consolidating his own party's base.
Talarico is performing better at this stage than Democrat Beto O'Rourke did six years ago in his famous near-miss against Ted Cruz. Despite losing that 2018 race, O'Rourke came within 2.6 percentage points in a state Republicans had controlled for two decades. Talarico's current position suggests Democrats have a genuine opportunity to break through in Republican Texas.
The comparison underscores how much momentum the Democratic candidate has built. With less than seven weeks until Election Day, Talarico holds a material lead rather than merely trailing close. The shift represents a dramatic turnaround from earlier this year, when Paxton entered the general election as the clear front-runner after defeating incumbent Sen. John Cornyn in the Republican primary runoff.
Republicans are treating this race as pivotal to controlling the Senate. Sen. Ted Cruz warned that a Democratic Texas victory could let Democrats "dominate the country for a century," signaling the broader national stakes both parties see at stake. Paxton has the backing of President Donald Trump, a move designed to shore up his standing with the GOP base.
Democrats need to flip four Republican-held Senate seats to regain their current 53-47 minority position and retake chamber control. A Texas flip would count as one of those four flips needed. For Paxton to regain the lead, he must win back crossover voters and consolidate the 6% of Trump voters still undecided, a task that grows more difficult as Election Day approaches.
Publishers
17
Articles
95
Reach
112