Supreme Court Awaits NEET Reform Report While Centre Outlines Structural Examination Changes

The bench hearing the matter comprised Justices P. S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe, while Solicitor General Tushar Mehta represented the Centre.
The Nilekani panel’s consultations included members of the earlier committee headed by former ISRO chairman K. Radhakrishnan, allowing the newer reform process to build on the previous panel’s recommendations.
The proceedings followed an August 19 Supreme Court direction requiring the Centre to report on implementation of recommendations from both the Radhakrishnan panel and the Nilekani committee.
The case is being heard through a batch of petitions, including a petition filed by advocate Tanvi Dubey on behalf of the Federation of All India Medical Association.
The Supreme Court is demanding action on NEET exam reforms after paper leaks disrupted 22.7 million medical students in 2026. Times Now News reported that the Nandan Nilekali-led reform panel must submit its first interim report by September 30, with the court planning a personal inspection of the National Testing Agency's upgraded headquarters to verify improvements are actually working.
Justices P. S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe stressed that the NTA needs permanent staff and dedicated departments—not borrowed government workers. Daily Pioneer reported that the Solicitor General confirmed the permanent structure is in place, but hired staff remain incomplete. The court has warned that decades-old recommendations cannot sit unimplemented.',
NEET-UG 2026 spiraled into scandal when question papers leaked before the exam. Over 23 million students faced delays, cancellations, and retakes. English Dainik Jagran reported that the education minister resigned following the crisis. The government then appointed two reform committees: the Radhakrishnan panel for broad policy fixes, and the Nilekani task force for actionable tech overhauls including possible Computer-Based Testing.
Justice Narasimha stated bluntly: "Permanency of the entire system is key. There should be a permanent setup, permanent staff, permanent verticals. Very less deputation should be there." The NTA had relied heavily on borrowed government workers rather than dedicated employees. Khel Ja reported that the court expressed frustration, saying past lessons went unlearned. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta admitted human resources remain "partially ensured at the moment," despite new infrastructure being ready.
The Nandan Nilekali panel has completed extensive consultations with the earlier Radhakrishnan committee members and must file its first interim report by September 30. The court ordered the Department of Personnel and Training to file an affidavit detailing all reform steps taken. News on Air confirmed the NTA is cooperating with state investigations into alleged irregularities. Justice Narasimha promised: "We will come there one day. Me and my brother to see if the system is working or not."
Advocates representing the Federation of All India Medical Association argue the NTA structure needs complete overhaul, not patch fixes. They demand digital locks on exam papers, center-wise result disclosures to detect fraud patterns, and possibly replacing the NTA entirely. The petitions highlight that recurring breaches violate students' fundamental rights to fair testing. The court has signaled sympathy, warning that recommendations risk remaining "just a report" without enforcement deadlines and public accountability.
Publishers
30
Articles
43
Reach
73